Corpus Iuris Hibernici
The Corpus Iuris Hibernici (cited as CIH) is a six-volume collection of the sources for the study of early Irish law (known as Brehon law) edited by D. A. Binchy. It presents a transcription of the manuscripts (Old Irish and Latin) relevant to this study.[2]: 136
The CIH was intended as a replacement for the Ancient Laws of Ireland (1865-1901), a series which relied on more limited sources and suffered from unscholarly and unreliable editorial work (with the exception of that done by Robert Atkinson). Prior to Binchy's work, the best sources for early Irish law were the unpublished transcripts of John O'Donovan and Eugene O'Curry, which circulated in scholarly libraries in a few (often incomplete) copies. Because of this, scholars like Rudolf Thurneysen were forced to rely on O'Donovan and O'Curry to correct errors in the published version, but nonetheless referred to the Ancient Laws of Ireland in their published footnotes for reasons of accessibility.[3]: 140–143
Though the CIH was highly rated for its editorial work, it received some criticism for its difficulty of use. Critics pointed out that it had no translations, no explanatory notes, few cross-references, and a table of contents which only listed the manuscripts transcribed.[2]: 137 [4] Myles Dillon called the work "austere".[5] T. M. Charles Edwards suggested that, rather than produce an edition of the manuscripts, a scholar of Binchy's stature could well have produced a critical edition of the texts themselves.[3]: 143–144 Fergus Kelly's Guide to early Irish law (1988) and Liam Breatnach's Companion to the Corpus iuris hibernici (2005) took on the task of identifying, describing, and making comprehensible these texts. Breatnach has identified 102 individual texts in the CIH and has incorporated elsewhere published texts (such as the archaic legal poem published previously by Binchy) into the corpus.[2]: 137–139
Bibliography
[edit]- Binchy, D. A. (1971). "An archaic legal poem". Celtica. 9: 152–168.
- Binchy, D. A. (1978). Corpus Iuris Hibernici (6 vols.). Dublin: Institute for Advanced Studies.
- Binchy, D. A. (1983). "Corpus Iuris Hibernici — Incipit or Finit Amen?". In Mac Eoin, Gearóid (ed.). Proceedings of the Sixth International Congress of Celtic Studies, 1979. Dublin: Institute for Advanced Studies. pp. 149–164.
- Breatnach, Liam (2005). A companion to the Corpus Iuris Hibernici. Early Irish Law Series. Vol. 5. Dublin: Institute for Advanced Studies.
- Kelly, Fergus (1988). A Guide to Early Irish Law. Early Irish Law Series. Vol. 3. Dublin: Institute for Advanced Studies.
- Melia, Daniel F. (1987). "A Computer-Assisted Index of the Corpus Juris Hibernici". In MacLennan, Gordon W. (ed.). Proceedings of the North American Congress of Celtic Studies, 1986. Ottawa: University of Ottawa. pp. 133–156.
References
[edit]- ^ Kelly, Fergus (1988). A Guide to Early Irish Law. Early Irish Law Series. Vol. 3. Dublin: Institute for Advanced Studies.
- ^ a b c McLeod, Neil (2005). "Review Article: A true companion to the Corpus Iuris Hibernici". Peritia. 19: 136–163. doi:10.1484/J.Peri.3.573.
- ^ a b Charles Edwards, T. M. (1980). "Review Article: The Corpus Iuris Hibernici". Studia Hibernica (20): 141–162. JSTOR 20496163.
- ^ Wagner, Heinrich (1981). "Review: Corpus Iuris Hibernici". Zeitschrift für celtische Philologie. 38 (1): 338–342. doi:10.1515/zcph.1981.38.1.338.
- ^ Ó Cathasaigh, Tomás (2006–2007). "Review: A companion to the Corpus Iuris Hibernici". Studia Hibernica (34): 193–195. JSTOR 40732138.
External links
[edit]- List of the manuscripts used in the Corpus Iuris Hibernici at Brehon Academy.